Paraíba Tourmaline
"There is always something new out of
Africa".
Pliny the Elder (23-79 AD), Historia
Naturalis
|
|
 |
|
|
Heitor Dimas
Barbosa, the discoverer of Paraíba
Tourmaline |
|
|
|
Without a doubt, Paraíba Tourmaline is the pop sensation
of the Tourmaline family and a true gemstone
superstar. Unearthed just under 20 years ago, in
the relatively short time since its discovery,
it has not only redefined the perception and
appeal of Tourmaline, but also gemmological
beauty itself. The late Masashi Furuya, former
director of the Japan Germany Gemmological
Laboratory, described Paraíba Tourmaline as
"electric blue brilliance burnt into our minds",
and looking at the picture opposite, you'll see
exactly what he meant. But we're getting ahead
of ourselves; let's take a moment to meet the
Tourmaline family.
If Tourmaline was a human family they would have
an ethnic diversity that would put the United
Nations to shame. Even its name alludes to this
multiplicity, Tourmaline is derived from the
Sinhalese, 'turmali' ('mixed parcel' or 'stone
with mixed colours'), which hints at some of the
historic confusion its many colours have
propagated with other gems. But more on this in
Rubellite click here. Similar to Garnet,
Tourmaline is a group of related minerals whose
differences in composition result in a plethora
of colours. While there are 13 different
mineralogical varieties of Tourmaline, you only
really need to worry about Elbaite. Named after
the island of its discovery (Elba) in Tuscany,
Italy, Elbaite is the backbone of Tourmaline
gemstones. A source of minerals during
antiquity, Elba is best known as the island of
Napoleon's exile in 1814.
Whether you give Tourmaline the distinction of
coming in more hues than any other gemstone or
attribute this to Diamonds or Fluorite, one
thing's for certain, Tourmaline definitely puts
the 'C' back in colour. Name a hue and in all
likelihood you'll find it in Tourmaline,
sometimes within the same gemstone! Even pure
'amethyst' purples have appeared since the
discovery of Mozambique Paraíba deposits (click
here). Tourmaline's different colours
are either identified by a colour prefix, such
as blue-green, green and pink, or a variety name
or prefix. These include Bi Colour Tourmaline
(two or more colours,
click here for more),
Canary Tourmaline (intense yellow from the
African nations of Malawi and Zambia), Cat's Eye
Tourmaline (chatoyant Tourmaline,
click here
for more), Colour Change Tourmaline (green to
red), Cuprian Tourmaline (non-Paraíba hues, but
still coloured by copper and manganese),
Indicolite (blue), Paraíba Tourmaline (blue to
green, coloured by copper and manganese),
Rubellite (red, click
here for more), and
Watermelon Tourmaline (pink inner green outer,
just like the fruit). Another prized, but
exceedingly rare variety is Chrome Tourmaline, a
vivid pure green East African Dravite coloured
by chromium and vanadium, the same elements that
make Emerald and Tsavorite. Last is Schorl
(Black Tourmaline), a variety that is naturally
abundant and once popular in mourning jewellery,
yet now commercially scarce because it is rarely
faceted. Nevertheless, interest in both Black
Tourmaline and Black Spinel has increased due to
the popularity of Black Diamonds. Due to its
double refractivity, Tourmaline is strongly
pleochroic (click
here for more) or getting
more technical, Tourmaline is the most dichroic
of all gemstones.
This means that each Tourmaline crystal has two
colours (dark and light), whose intensity
changes when viewed from different angles. This
is covered in more detail shortly. While some
gemstones look better in natural daylight and
others in artificial (incandescent) light, a
gemstone's colours should ideally remain
beautiful in any light source. Despite this, all
Tourmalines are 'day gems', meaning they
typically look their very best in natural light.
The yellow glare of artificial lights will
sometimes accentuate grey and brown tones which
may otherwise be invisible. As always, be guided
by common sense and your preferences, paying
heed to the inherent characteristics of each
type.
Any historical contempt for Tourmaline's
look-alike abilities evaporated overnight when
Paraíba Tourmaline hit the world market. The
beginning of this gem begins with one man,
Heitor Dimas Barbosa, the discoverer of Paraíba
Tourmaline. In the early eighties, he was a
'garimpeiro' (small-scale miner) who became
infatuated by the beautiful brilliance of blue
Tourmaline crystal collected by a friend. Heitor
was no quitter and around 1987 he hit pay dirt
in mines near the village of São José da Batalha
in Paraíba, Brazil. Named for the location of
its discovery, by 1989 Paraíba Tourmaline was
shifting perceptions and paradigms, making any
respectable gem dealer go weak at the knees. In
his book, 'Gemstones: Quality and Value, Volume
1', Yasukazu Suwa nicely sums this up stating,
"The appeal of Paraíba Tourmaline far exceeds
that of other gems, to the point where they are
desired even by people who are accustomed to
seeing a variety of gemstones". The main reason
for this is its vivid colours, characterised by
a sizzling, electric, neon or fluorescent
appearance as well as a distinctive transparency
that affords Paraíba Tourmaline's fine
brilliance. In a way, colour in Paraíba
Tourmaline is perhaps a dichotomy, in that its
typically medium toned, sometimes almost pastel
hues, still have intensity. This is unusual and
a big reason for its appeal. Clarity and size
play second fiddle in Paraíba Tourmaline; colour
is the beauty gauge. Variously described as
Caribbean blue, peacock, copper-green,
neon-aquamarine, swimming pool blue or turquoise
blue, from a gemmological perspective, the
colours range from bluish-green, blue-green,
greenish-blue, blue and bluish-violet. As these
finite colours, along with its composition, now
define this gemstone, I've included a handy
colour chart to show you the accepted range.
While its vivid blues are the most popular and
expensive, all its colours are unique, with gems
displaying a greater neon intensity increasing
in value. Like Emerald, Paraíba Tourmaline often
has visible inclusions, although this varies
somewhat depending on origin, with Mozambique
Paraíba Tourmaline typically far cleaner (and
larger) than those from Brazil. While Paraíba
Tourmaline is not always eye-clean, this is
tolerable as long as it doesn't nullify beauty.
Paraíba Tourmaline's transparency is sometimes a
double-edged sword, in that its shows inclusions
that wouldn't be visible in other gems. Large
eye-clean (no visible inclusions when the gem is
examined six inches from the naked eye) electric
blue specimens, like the 8.7 carat gem pictured
at the beginning of this section, are rare and
priced accordingly. Once you've settled on a
Paraíba Tourmaline colour and clarity that fits
your taste and budget, look for a good shape and
overall appearance. Available in a variety of
shapes and cuts since the discovery of the
Mozambique deposits, Paraíba Tourmaline are most
commonly seen in ovals and pears.
While Paraíba Tourmaline is hugely popular, it's
currently difficult to purchase any rough on the
open market; anyone who has it appears to be
sitting on it. As with anything scarce,
beautiful and in demand, its prices reflect its
popularity. With mechanised mining now happening
in the Mozambique Paraíba Tourmaline deposit and
further exploration of the surrounding area,
it's likely Africa not Brazil will secure the
future of this uniquely beautiful gem.
Paraíba Tourmaline Colours
 |
|
 |
Apatite
Apatite is not a Tourmaline, but since the discovery of
saturated neon 'Paraíba' blues in Madagascar
near Fort Dauphin in 1995, Apatite has garnered
increased recognition. This is the popularity
power of Paraíba Tourmaline. Not only has it
secured its own superstar status in the gem
world, but it has also propelled interest in
other Tourmalines as well as similar vividly
coloured gemstones. Apatite's name comes from
the Greek 'apatao', which means 'to deceive' and
looking at this example, it is certainly apt;
superficially, it's a pretty convincing Paraíba
Tourmaline substitute. Also available in
'emerald' greens, Apatite is rare over 1 carat.
|
 |
Blue Green Tourmaline
Too green to be Indicolite and too blue to be Green
Tourmaline, this spectacular gem from the
Democratic Republic of the Congo clearly shows
the effects of Tourmaline's signature diochrosim,
a type of pleochroism showing two colours (click
here for more). Depending on how they are
cut, lighter toned specimens like this gem
sometimes display the primary and secondary dichroic blues and greens sparkling on neighbouring facets, creating an attractive
mosaic effect. In this book, I have separated
the bluish-green 'peacock' hues of these
Tourmalines from Green Tourmaline and Indicolite
for ease of comprehension.
|
 |
Cuprian Tourmaline
Cuprian Tourmaline is the name for the copper-rich (Cuprian)
Mozambique Tourmalines that do not fall within
the acceptable colours for Paraíba Tourmaline.
Extremely collectable for the clever gem buyer,
Cuprian Tourmaline is a fairly new gemstone,
only appearing commercially since the discovery
of Paraíba Tourmaline's Mozambique deposits. As
Cuprian and Paraíba Tourmaline are the same
except for their colour, apply similar
evaluation criteria. The colours seen in Cuprian
Tourmaline include burnt oranges, dusty roses,
lavenders, purples, reddish-purples and yellows.
As with all gems, especially unusual exotics,
your personal preferences regarding beauty
should be the deciding factor.
Green Tourmaline
Whether vividly trying to look like Emerald or embodying
lighter tones reminiscent of Paraíba Tourmaline,
Green Tourmaline is a gem worthy of
consideration. In fact, just like Tourmaline's
blue and red varieties, Green Tourmaline often
has a beautiful distinct 'green' all of its
own (click
here for more). The 'green' of
Paraíba and Green Tourmaline are fairly
discernable, particularly when they are viewed
together. Green Tourmaline's colours range from
pure 'emeralds' to yellowish-greens. Like most
gems, we are looking for the happy medium,
intensely colourful, but not too light nor too
dark. Different Tourmalines have different
degrees of clarity and unlike Paraíba Tourmaline
and Rubellite, Green Tourmaline is usually
eye-clean. So much so, that I'd steer clear of
visually included examples. Darker specimens
lose brilliance and beauty, and this is why
Tourmaline's darker blues, reds and greens are
oriented by the lapidary to display the lighter
of its two dichroic (pleochroic) colours. As
Tourmaline crystals are typically elongated,
especially when mined from their host pegmatite
(a coarse-grained rock with exceptionally large
crystals formed from magma with a high
proportion of water), they are often cut into
baguette or octagon-shaped gems. Too much yellow
or brown can result in combat greens. The main
sources for Green Tourmaline are Brazil,
Namibia, Nigeria, Madagascar and Mozambique.
Indicolite
Visually
distinct from Paraíba Tourmaline, Indicolite
(also spelt Indigolite or indigolith) is derived
from the Latin 'indicum' (a blue dye obtained
from various plants) and from the Greek 'lithos'
(stone) for its indigo hues. Due to its
geological rarity, after Paraíba Tourmaline and
Chrome Tourmaline, fine pure blue Indicolite is
more valuable than Rubellite, Bi Colour
Tourmaline, Pink Tourmaline and Green
Tourmaline. The propensity of pleochroism (dichroism)
to darken Indicolite so it loses transparency,
brilliance and beauty can sometimes make it a
difficult gemstone for lapidaries. All
Tourmaline can be challenging to cut, but in
Indicolite, the table of the gem has to be
orientated to not only achieve the best possible
weight and clarity, but also to minimise the
impact of its darker colour. Similar to Green
Tourmaline, Indicolite is usually eye-clean. In
his book, 'Secrets of the Gem Trade', Richard
Wise compares the search for a Sapphire Blue
Tourmaline to that of the Holy Grail and in my
experience, he's right on the money. In my years
in the gem industry, the Indicolite pictured
here comes closest to looking visually similar
to a Blue Sapphire. I debated on whether to
include this photograph as it's definitely the
exception rather than the rule. Most fine
Indicolite I have seen is much darker, but with
distinct neon flashes. Whilst the historic
source of Sapphire Blue Indicolite is Brazil,
this gem hails from the Democratic Republic of
the Congo. In my opinion, blue characterises
this variety and specimens with visible greens
should not be called Indicolite.
|
Prefixes like 'Ceylon'
or 'Kashmir' not only denote a Sapphire
origin, but also imply a quality
expectation. The biggest thing to
remember for Paraíba Tourmaline is that
it's a lot more than an origin.
Tourmaline's array of colours is
typically down to trace amounts of
chromium, iron, manganese and vanadium,
but with Paraíba Tourmaline it is copper
and manganese, an uncanny combo for
Tourmaline, that not only makes it
beautiful, but also geologically scarce.
While the original Batalha Mine in
Paraíba was ostensibly exhausted several
years after its discovery, new but
limited Brazilian deposits were later
discovered in the neighbouring state of
Rio Grande do Norte in 1991 (Mulunga
Mine) and 1995 (Quintos Mine), and again
in Paraíba in 2006 (Glorious Mine). But
just as Pliny said in the 1st
century, "there is always something new
out of Africa". The newer African
discoveries, first in Nigeria (Edoukou
and Ofiki circa 2000) and then in
Mozambique (Mavuco 2001, although the
gems didn't appear in the marketplace
until 2005) have helped fulfil the
demand for this 'aristocratic'
Tourmaline, not only making it more
available and affordable, but also
promoting it as a mainstream jewellery
gemstone. The discovery of non-Brazilian
Paraíba wasn't without controversy and
led to marketplace terms such 'Paraíba
Africana' and 'Paraíba-type'. In 2006,
the LMHC (Laboratory Manual
Harmonisation Committee) decided that
because they are indistinguishable using
standard gemmological tests, blue
(electric blue, neon blue or violet
blue), bluish-green to greenish-blue or
green copper-rich Cuprian Elbaite
Tourmaline with a medium to high
saturation and tone of any origin can be
called 'Paraíba'. As gemstones don't
recognise borders, origin typically
doesn't define a variety, yet some in
the gem biz continue to disagree with
the LMHC's decision. This came to a head
when David Sherman (Paraíba.com) brought
a lawsuit against the AGTA (American Gem
Trade Association), claiming that use of
the name 'Paraíba' for any
copper-bearing Tourmaline regardless of
origin has hurt him financially. As
reported by JCK (Jewellers Circular
Keystone) on 31st October,
2008, a
federal court dismissed the case. The
truth is 'Paraíba' was never just a
place name; it is all about copper and colour. For me, I'm listening to the
seven gemmological laboratories that
make up the LMHC and the endorsement by
CIBJO (click here for more) for the
use of 'Paraíba' for other origins. To
use an old analogy, if it looks like a
duck and quacks like a duck, it must be
a duck. Nevertheless, all things being
equal, Paraíba Tourmaline with a
certified Brazilian origin will
typically demand a premium. Just make
sure you're paying for quality, not just
pedigree. |
|